Vickie Collins, dabbling in culture and just being herself here at Multiply

Blog EntryTwo books: Grief, and 5 peopleOct 21, '07 2:33 AM
for everyone

Lately, it seems that I have been doing a lot of reading, and watching of movies. Yesterday, I reviewed a movie, today it is two books that I have read over the last week or so. Both of the books seems to have an affect on me.

The first book is by a gay author, Andrew Hollerman and is named simply Grief. His homosexuality fiqures in but only as a side line to what is really a novel about sorrow. The protagonist has lost his mother, and moves to Washington DC for a while. The stated reason is to teach a class for a friend but in addition, there are signs that he is hoping to "drown" his sorrow and guilt over his mother's death. He returns home, and the grief is still there with him. I found the book a bit unsettling perhaps because I was hoping that somehow there was a magic formula that would allow me to get over my own very real grief over several occurances over the last year. It seems that in both the book and in the outside world, there is the hope that somehow we will "get over it". In reality, we dont really get over it so much as learn to live with it--the grief. The book served as a poignant reminder that even thought a certain period, in my case a year, has elapsed doesnt mean that suddenly the pain is gone. I recommend this book for anyone that wants to learn about grief, likes a good story, or is dealing with their own grief..might just be cathartic.

The other book is The Five People You Meet in Heaven, by Mitch Albom, who also wrote Tuesdays with Morrie. I found the book to be rather elementary. The general story is about a guy dying and going to heaven and meeting 5 people that he had had an impact on while alive. Especially in face of the fact that this book was on the Oprah Winfrey book list, I was sorely disappointed. The concept was a good one, however, I was actually glad that it was only 196 pages of very easy reading. I had hoped for a more interesting book, one that I would be happy to read 300-400 pages, but such was not the case with this one.

I dont recommend this book, unless the concept is new to you and you want a very quick read. Neither of the books is what could be called "escapism", however, Grief, while being disturbing, was thought provoking. With Five People, I was left thinking "is that all there is?" I encourage other viewpoints and would appreciate any comments.



vickiecollins wrote on Oct 28, '07
I also read The Five People You Meet in Heaven, and I thought it was one of the most interesting books I've ever read. Did you know it was also a mini-series on TV last year? I liked the book better. It makes you realize that each one of us plays a part that makes up the whole universe, and how we effect each other even after death. I actually recommended this book also on a past Book Tuesday not too long ago. You can copy and paste the URL to get to it at:

http://blog.360.yahoo.com/blog-CfyfZ3E9aLJVTKEd1NE1fA--?cq=1&tag=thefivepeopleyoumeetinheaven

Tuesday October 16, 2007 - 08:32pm (EDT) Laurita
vickiecollins wrote on Oct 28, '07
Grief sounds interesting, about the other book I remember Laurita's review, she recommended it. It's good to have such different opinions, now we should all read the book and find out whether we agree with you or with Laurita. Or maybe a third opinion will come along. Thanks for joining Book Tuesday, good night.

Wednesday October 17, 2007 - 03:01am (BST) Red Witch
vickiecollins wrote on Oct 28, '07
Thanks for the reviews...Grief sounds like an intriguing novel, one I would probably like. The 5 People not so much -- I had heard others raving about it and so I picked it up once in an airport and skimmed through it. It did seem pretty simplistic and sappy. Yes we do have an effect on others' lives, but I would prefer to get that message in a more subtle way rather than having it presented in such a didactic style.

Wednesday October 17, 2007 - 01:38pm (PDT) Marla
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help

Template design - Copyright © 2005 sonnenvogel.com All rights reserved.